When I consider how to approach an area of muscular discomfort, I want to understand more than where it hurts. I also want to know how touch feels to that person, what they are anticipating, and whether they feel comfortable participating in the decisions we make during the session.
In my earlier articles, I examined fascia as adaptive tissue and massage as sensory input. The next question brings those ideas together: how does the experience surrounding the hands-on work influence the way someone receives it?
Recent research is helping us ask that question more precisely. Pain sensitivity, emotional state, sleep, previous experiences, expectations, and the therapeutic relationship deserve attention. They do not all influence the same outcomes, and we should be careful about treating them as one explanation for why someone feels tense.
Terminology used in this post
- Sensory processing
- How the nervous system receives and interprets information, including touch and pressure.
- Affective touch
- Touch considered in terms of its emotional qualities, including how pleasant or unpleasant it feels.
- Contextual factors
- Features surrounding an intervention, such as expectations, communication, prior experiences, and the setting.
- Therapeutic relationship
- The working relationship between a client and practitioner, including communication and collaboration.
- Treatment dose
- The amount and characteristics of the work, including pressure, pace, duration, and repetition.
My position: Comfort and communication belong in clinical reasoning alongside anatomy and technique. They help us understand how someone is experiencing the work. The evidence does not establish that relaxation makes a particular technique more effective—or that a client needs to relax successfully before care can help.
The person receiving the work brings more than a pain score
The same person can arrive for two appointments with different needs. Before repeating an approach, I want to understand what has changed: their symptoms, sleep, energy, expectations, or comfort with the session itself.
Pain sensitivity and emotional state can influence different aspects of the experience. In the fibromyalgia study, chronic pain intensity best predicted reduced touch pleasantness, while anxiety and depression related differently to other sensory measures. That finding argues for asking specific questions rather than assuming that someone who finds touch uncomfortable is simply anxious. Albinni et al., 2026
It also matters which outcome we mean. Whether touch feels pleasant and whether it changes pain are separate questions. A related 2026 experiment found that depression and childhood trauma history were associated with differences in touch-related pain modulation. These laboratory associations do not tell us how to predict an individual’s massage outcome or justify drawing conclusions about their history. Albinni et al., 2026, pain modulation
Sleep deserves attention alongside mood. A systematic review found that sleep disturbance can alter pain perception, with differences across sleep-loss conditions and participant characteristics. This evidence predates the newer touch studies, but it provides an important foundation: sensitivity should not automatically be interpreted as a psychological response. Rouhi et al., 2023
For my practice, that supports a simple question: “How have you been sleeping?” I would also ask about unusual fatigue, recent exertion, or a change in symptoms. Those answers help establish what needs consideration; they do not identify a cause by themselves.
Previous experiences and sensory preferences help give contact its meaning. Someone may appreciate sustained pressure but dislike repetitive stroking. Another person may be comfortable with contact only after understanding where and how it will be applied. A recent theoretical review proposes that prior experience, expectations, trust, perceived control, and current bodily state interact with the physical stimulus. It offers a framework to investigate, rather than a proven formula for better outcomes. Ruchkin & Koposov, 2026
I would ask what someone wants me to know about touch, positioning, or previous treatment. They can describe a preference without explaining the personal history behind it.
The setting and the practitioner’s behavior are variables we can actually adjust. Privacy, draping, temperature, sound, positioning, and the amount of conversation belong in that assessment. So does whether my explanation is clear and whether a request for change produces a meaningful response.
I regard these as practical care decisions. Their importance does not depend on claiming that each adjustment produces a specific nervous-system effect.
Health and medication changes also belong in the intake. I want clients to mention relevant changes so I can consider whether the planned work remains appropriate. That is different from assuming a medication explains their sensitivity or suggesting they change it.
Together, these considerations give us a broader starting point. The question becomes: what is this person experiencing today, what can we appropriately adapt, and what outcome will help us judge whether the adaptation was useful?
A quieter room or a different position may improve comfort. A change in pressure may make contact more acceptable. Whether those adjustments also improve pain, movement, or lasting function needs its own assessment.
Trust becomes useful through collaboration
A systematic integrative review published in 2026 examined the therapeutic relationship in musculoskeletal physiotherapy. It identified communication, partnership, individualized care, and support for the patient’s agency as central components. Its purpose was to clarify the relationship and how it is assessed, rather than establish how much trust changes a treatment’s effect. Puustinen, Kvist, & Stolt, 2026
Although physiotherapy and massage are different settings, I find that framework useful for examining my own practice.
Trust needs something concrete behind it. If I ask whether pressure is comfortable, the answer needs to influence what I do. If someone requests a different position, that preference belongs in the plan. Collaboration is visible in those decisions.
For clients, that means there should be room to give an answer other than “fine.” For practitioners, it asks whether our questions genuinely leave room for the work to change.
Improvement cannot always be assigned to one technique
A small 2025 trial compared five minutes of a suboccipital myofascial technique with light-touch sham treatment in 30 people without symptoms. The researchers found no statistically significant difference between the groups’ changes in pressure-pain threshold, neck movement, or position sense. The study did not establish which contextual factors contributed, and its findings cannot be assumed to apply to clients with neck pain. Safran & Kaya, 2025
This is why I want to distinguish an observation from its explanation. An improvement after hands-on care is worth examining. Assigning it entirely to a specific maneuver requires additional evidence.
For practitioners, this creates a useful responsibility: remain interested in the result without becoming attached to one explanation for it.
Relaxation is information, not a task to perform
I would not ask a client to make the session successful by becoming sufficiently relaxed.
Someone may arrive worried, uncomfortable, distracted, or unsure what to expect. My responsibility is to work with the information available and offer appropriate choices. A client should not have to disclose personal circumstances to justify a preference for lighter contact, a quieter session, or a different position.
When I notice someone holding their breath or appearing uncomfortable, I would ask what they are experiencing. I would not use that observation to diagnose anxiety or conclude that they are resisting the work.
I also want to keep comfort and effectiveness distinct. Feeling settled during a session is worthwhile. Whether the original concern improves is another question we need to follow.
What this changes for skilled hands
My proposed application of this research is to make adaptation more deliberate:
- Establish what the client hopes will become easier.
- Ask about touch preferences and previous experiences that they want considered.
- Explain the approach and agree on how to communicate adjustments.
- Change pressure, pace, duration, or positioning in response to their experience.
- Reassess the original concern and ask what carries into daily life.
That does not give us a formula for making every session work. It gives us a clearer way to understand the response.
When we ask whether greater relaxation allows more effective bodywork, we need to define “effective.” Do we mean more comfortable contact, easier movement, less pain, or improvement that lasts? Those outcomes deserve separate attention.
The contribution I want to make as a practitioner is to connect the physical work with the circumstances in which it is received—and to remain precise about what improves, what does not, and what we still need to understand.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not medical advice. New numbness, weakness, unexplained weight loss, bowel or bladder changes, fever, or severe pain should be evaluated by a licensed medical provider.
Care you can participate in
At Balanced Healing in Colorado Springs, I want the approach to make sense to the person receiving it. If persistent muscular discomfort is affecting an activity you care about, we can discuss whether a session is appropriate and what we would evaluate together.
Clients: Ask about a session.
Practitioners: I welcome conversations about how you connect research, clinical judgment, and the client’s experience. Get in touch.
References
Albinni, B., et al. (2026). Modulation of pain by affective touch: Effects of childhood trauma, depression, chronic pain, and spinal segment. The Journal of Physiology. doi:10.1113/JP290242
Rouhi, S., Topcu, J., Egorova-Brumley, N., & Jordan, A. S. (2023). The impact of sleep disturbance on pain perception: A systematic review examining the moderating effect of sex and age. Sleep Medicine Reviews, 71, 101835. doi:10.1016/j.smrv.2023.101835
Albinni, B., Zimmerman, M., Alasha, V., Ross, J., Crankshaw, L., Hu, S. R., Schuster, N., & Case, L. (2026). Distinct effects of fibromyalgia pain, depression and anxiety on perception of affective touch and pain. The Journal of Physiology. doi:10.1113/JP290243
Ruchkin, V., & Koposov, R. A. (2026). Touch, temperature, and relief: A multilevel integrative model of hedonic regulation in massage and thermal therapies. Frontiers in Physiology, 17, 1888366. doi:10.3389/fphys.2026.1888366
Puustinen, S., Kvist, T., & Stolt, M. (2026). The core components and instruments of the therapeutic relationship in musculoskeletal physiotherapy: A systematic integrative review. Musculoskeletal Care, 24(2), e70219. doi:10.1002/msc.70219
Safran, E., & Kaya, Y. (2025). Contextual and placebo effects of suboccipital myofascial release: Evaluating its influence on pain threshold, cervical range of motion, and proprioception. BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders, 26, 502. doi:10.1186/s12891-025-08741-6
Back to the blog